How to Calculate Automation ROI: A Worked Alberta Example
Calculate automation ROI with real 2026 payroll costs: a loaded hourly rate with CPP and EI, a two-week baseline, payback months, and the break-even floor.

To calculate automation ROI, multiply the hours a task takes each year by what one of those hours really costs you, take the share the automation removes, and subtract what the automation costs to build and run. Most estimates go wrong on the second number: they use the wage, not the loaded cost. Below is the whole calculation with 2026 Canadian payroll rates and an Alberta calendar, so you can swap in your own figures.
Step 1: Work out the loaded hourly cost
An employee costs more than their salary, and works fewer hours than 52 weeks × 40. Both effects raise the cost of an hour. Here is the arithmetic for a hypothetical office coordinator in Edmonton on a $52,000 salary. Replace each input with yours.
Salary: $52,000
Employer CPP: 5.95% of earnings above the $3,500 basic exemption, so 5.95% × $48,500 = $2,885.75 (CRA, 2026 CPP rates)
Employer EI: 1.4 times the 1.63% employee rate, so 2.282% × $52,000 = $1,186.64 (CRA, 2026 EI rates)
Benefits: $3,000 a year (an assumption; use your plan's real premium, plus your WCB rate)
Total cost: $59,072.39
Now the hours actually worked. Alberta employees are owed at least two weeks of vacation in their first four years (vacation pay is 4% of wages), and the province has 9 general holidays.
2,080 paid hours − 80 vacation hours − 72 holiday hours = 1,928 hours worked
$59,072.39 ÷ 1,928 = $30.64 per hour worked
That is about 22% more than the $25.00 a straight $52,000 ÷ 2,080 would suggest, before counting sick days, training or meetings. If you skip this step, every automation looks less valuable than it is.
Step 2: Measure a two-week baseline
Don't estimate how long the task takes. Ask the people who do it to log it for two normal weeks: start time, end time, and how many items they handled (invoices, intake forms, quotes). Two weeks smooths out a slow Monday and a busy month-end without turning into a project.
Write down three numbers from the log:
- Hours per week on the task, across everyone who touches it.
- Items per week, so you can see the cost per item.
- Errors or rework, anything that had to be fixed or redone, and how long the fix took.
In our example, two people spend a combined 12 hours a week keying customer intake forms into the job system. Reading a form and filling in a record is a typical job for AI data extraction, which is why it makes a good example.
Step 3: Calculate payback and ROI
The worked example as one chain. Every number is an input you can replace.
Continue the example. Over about 48 working weeks, 12 hours a week is 576 hours, which costs 576 × $30.64 = $17,648.64 a year. Suppose the automation handles 75% of the forms and a person reviews the rest: that is 432 hours, or $13,236.48 a year, back.
Now the cost side, using Clovai's published prices as the example. A build starts from $8,000 (the $2,500 audit is credited against it, so the audit adds nothing once you build), and the optional AI Care Plan starts from $400 a month, or $4,800 a year.
Net saving a year: $13,236.48 − $4,800 = $8,436.48
Payback: $8,000 ÷ $8,436.48 = 0.95 years, about 11 months
Three-year net: (3 × $8,436.48) − $8,000 = $17,309.44
Payback in months is easier to explain to a partner or a bank than a percentage. If you need ROI as a percentage anyway, use (three-year net ÷ total three-year cost): $17,309.44 ÷ ($8,000 + $14,400) = 77%.
When is an automation not worth it?
When the running cost eats the saving. Divide the yearly running cost by the loaded hourly rate and by the share automated: $4,800 ÷ $30.64 ÷ 0.75 ≈ 209 hours of task time a year, or about 4.4 hours a week. Below that, a $400-a-month plan costs more than the time it saves, and the honest answer is a cheaper tool, a better template, or leaving it alone. Run this floor before anyone quotes you a build.
What to count, and what to leave out
- Count: hours removed, at the loaded rate; rework you measured in the baseline; software you can cancel because of the automation.
- Count separately, if you can measure it: faster replies to leads, invoices sent the same day, fewer missed deadlines. These are often worth more than the hours, but put them next to the calculation, not inside it.
- Leave out: "staff can focus on higher-value work" unless you know what that work is and what it earns.
Check it after launch
Repeat the two-week log 30 days after go-live and again at 90 days. Compare hours, items handled and errors against the baseline. If the saving is below the estimate, the usual cause is that the review step takes longer than planned, which is fixable with better rules for what goes to a person.
Our guide to what AI automation costs in Canada breaks down the build and running costs in more detail, and the free automation checklist helps you choose which task to log first. If you'd rather have someone run the baseline and the numbers for you, that is the first half of the AI Automation Audit: $2,500, five business days, one workflow, GST added where it applies. Request the audit and the roadmap comes back with the payback worked out for each option.
Put these ideas to work
Score one of your workflows in two minutes, with no email needed. If it is worth automating, the fixed-price audit puts the plan in writing.